Eco215

My Big Idea – Fixing Nigeria’s Fiscal Arm: A Case For Urgent Reform

Nigeria Macro Weekly – #2025.08: Yields slide further at the February bond sale, Economic growth quickens and a time to reform Nigeria’s fiscal bureaucracy

Yields curve flattens, DMO oversale at the February 2025 bond auction: At the highly anticipated February 2025 bond auction, where the DMO initially offered NGN350 billion, demand was exceptionally strong, with total bids reaching approximately NGN1.6 trillion—reflecting trends observed in the secondary market. In response, the DMO opted to oversell, allotting NGN910 billion in total. The stop rates on the 5-year and 7-year bonds settled at 19.2% (previous: 21.8%) and 19.33% (previous: 22.5%), respectively. Meanwhile, secondary market yields continued to decline following the DMO’s unexpected withdrawal of the 10-year bond ahead of the auction, further fueling bullish sentiment. Bond yields have rallied sharply in recent weeks, initially driven by the NTB redemption plan outlined in the Q1 2025 issuance calendar. This was followed by the rebasing of CPI, which reset inflation expectations and the growing market sentiment that the DMO deliberately accelerates a decline in the yield curve.

Figure 1: Naira Yield Curve

Source: FMDQ

President Tinubu signs the 2025 budget: After several delays, President Tinubu signed the 2025 budget though details remain scant with nothing on the Budget Office website or that of the Finance Ministry. The new budget continues the theme of expansionism associated with the headline expenditure envelope set at NGN55trillion (20% of 2024 nominal GDP). For those who look at Nigeria’s fiscal accounts, much of the trend growth in Nigeria’s budget is driven by an attempt to mask the elevated nature of borrowing costs: the great game. Essentially, Nigeria’s  

 Though one might add that in recent years, a portion also reflects the rising share of non-oil tax receipts arising from FX translation effects and higher tax rates. For context, non-oil tax collections are up from around NGN1

Nigeria’s economic growth quickened over Q4: Nigeria’s economy appears to have shrugged off the effects of the sharp currency depreciation earlier in the year, as data from the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) shows that real GDP grew by 3.84% in Q4, up from 3.46% in Q3. This marks the fastest pace of expansion in twelve quarters, driven largely by non-oil GDP growth—a shift from the oil-dependent pattern seen in previous quarters. While oil sector growth remained modest at 1.5%, non-oil GDP grew by 3.96%, propelled by a 7% expansion in the Services sector. Key contributors included Telecommunications (+6%), Financial Services (+28%), and Transportation (+19%). In contrast, growth across other sectors was relatively subdued: Manufacturing (+1.5%), Agriculture (+1.8%), Trade (+1.2%), and Construction (+2.9%). Notably, oil refining saw a 10% increase, the first in 24 quarters, signaling a revival in domestic refining capacity with the commencement of operations at the Dangote Refinery. Overall, the Q4 performance lifted 2024 full-year GDP growth to 3.4%, up from 2.74% in 2023.

Figure: Non-Oil GDP Attribution

Source: NBS

Looking ahead to 2025, attention turns to the anticipated NBS GDP rebasing exercise, which aims to update GDP indices from 2014 to 2023. The NBS has already signaled significant shifts in output composition, with real estate expected to surpass oil and gas in size. On the growth front, refining activity is poised to be a key driver, supported by increased capacity from the Dangote and Port Harcourt refineries. Meanwhile, oil production started the year on a strong note in January, suggesting sustained momentum. Additionally, an improving FX liquidity environment is expected to bolster growth in the non-oil sector. Given the surprises in the CPI exercise, not sure it is worth trying to read the tea leaves on GDP numbers until the NBS puts out its forecast. 

Nigeria’s Eurobond yields continue to rally: Despite softer oil prices, Nigeria’s Eurobond yields rallied further as the goldilocks moment continues.  With budget passage, the DMO should look to capture the current sentiment by tapping global debt markets with a sale given the USD1.1billion maturity in November. 

Figure 2: Nigeria Eurobond Curve

Source: DMO

My Big Idea – Fixing Nigeria’s Fiscal Arm: A Case for Urgent Reform

Looking through Nigeria’s finance ministry, one cannot help but despair at the weak capacity that exists. The contrast between the monetary arm, represented by the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), and the finance ministry is stark. The CBN operates as a professional and data-driven institution, while the Federal Ministry of Finance remains a hollowed-out bureaucracy plagued by inefficiency, fragmentation, and a lack of transparency. This imbalance has severe consequences, as fiscal policy is a critical pillar of economic management. Over the years, the finance ministry has been stripped of its core functions, with critical fiscal roles scattered across multiple agencies. The Budget Office struggles with institutional capacity, the Debt Management Office (DMO) operates independently, and tax policy remains divided among competing entities, including the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) and other tax boards. This fragmentation has led to poor policy coordination and weak fiscal management.  Furthermore, the ministry is subject to frequent restructuring, further weakening its capacity. For instance, the Buhari administration separated the budget office from finance in its first term, only to reintegrate it later, undermining institutional stability. Moreover, various governments have bypassed the finance ministry through presidential committees and special advisers, further diminishing its authority. Unlike the CBN, which maintains a well-structured bureaucracy and transparent reporting systems, the finance ministry’s website is a testament to its dysfunction—offering little useful data or critical information but abundant personnel biographies of government officials. 

To restore credibility and effectiveness, Nigeria must undertake a radical restructuring of its finance ministry, consolidating key functions and embedding professional standards.

To rebuild Nigeria’s fiscal capacity, urgent steps must be taken:

  1. Consolidate Fiscal Functions: Key institutions such as the Budget Office, DMO, and tax policy units should be reintegrated back into the finance ministry. The separation of powers and capacity has undermined the fiscal arm. The government’s plan to establish a unified Nigeria Revenue Service (NRS) should be fast-tracked to streamline tax collection and enhance efficiency. The NRS should remain a purely operational entity to ensure efficiency, with tax policy set by the finance ministry.
  2. Strengthen Fiscal Policy Research: A dedicated Fiscal Policy and Macroeconomic Research Department must be established, mirroring the CBN’s research department, to provide an independent second perspective on economic data, debt figures, and expenditure reports.
  3. Enact an Omnibus Fiscal Reform Law that creates a professional merit driven fiscal bureaucracy: A comprehensive law should mandate fiscal discipline, professional staffing, and regular reporting, ensuring that the finance ministry operates with autonomy and strong technical expertise.

Nigeria cannot afford to have a dysfunctional fiscal arm while relying on a well-run monetary institution. The finance ministry should be restructured into a powerful, professional institution that sets Nigeria’s fiscal strategy, just as the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN does for monetary policy. The Minister of Finance must seize the moment to push for these reforms, ensuring that the ministry regains its rightful place as a cornerstone of economic governance. The time for action is now.


Discover more from Eco215

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Discover more from Eco215

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Scroll to Top