Eco215

Nigeria’s Fiscal Deficit Shock: CBN Reveals N15.5 Trillion Gap, Contradicting Finance Ministry’s Optimistic Figures

Nigeria Macro Weekly

Nigeria’s oil production recovered in April driven by higher Forcados output: Nigeria’s oil production rose by 5% in April 2025 to 1.68 million barrels per day (mbpd), driven primarily by a sharp rebound in output from the Forcados export terminal, which surged 43% to 312,000 barrels per day, according to data from the Nigerian Upstream Petroleum Regulatory Commission (NUPRC). Output at other major terminals was largely stable, with Bonny unchanged at 246kbpd, Qua Iboe slightly higher at 145kbpd (+2%), Bonga flat at 123kbpd (-0.2%), and Escravos steady at 143kbpd (+0.1%). The strength at Forcados helped offset declines at several other terminals, including Brass, which fell 31% to 25kbpd, Akpo down 10% to 51kbpd, Erha down 15% to 62kbpd, and Egina down 10% to 64kbpd. The uptick in April marks a welcome recovery following a subdued start to the year, with Forcados once again playing a central role in lifting overall crude output.

Figure 1: Nigeria Oil Production.

Source: NUPRC

Inflation slowed over April, still noisy underlying patterns: The National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) released April 2025 inflation data showing a notable slowdown in headline inflation to 23.7% year-on-year, reversing the uptick recorded in March. This was driven largely by a deceleration in the monthly inflation rate to 1.86% (March: 3.9%).

The improvement appears to stem primarily from the core CPI basket, which slowed significantly to 1.3% month-on-month in April (March: 3.7%). Subcomponents within the core CPI posted broad declines: Utilities (4.3% from 12.2%), ICT (2.9% from 4.5%), Clothing (2.5% from 8.1%), Health (3.1% from 10.2%), and Transportation (1.5% from 2%). However, the food inflation data remains difficult to interpret. The food CPI came in at 2.1%, only marginally lower than March’s 2.2%, yet none of the subcomponents posted growth above 2%: Farm produce (+0.9%), Imported food (+1.2%), Alcoholic beverages (+1.8%), and Food & non-alcoholic beverages actually declined (-0.1%). Notably, there’s a stark divergence between urban food inflation (+0.04%) and rural food inflation (+6.2%), further clouding the data. 

Figure 1: 2025 Inflation Data: Actual and Forecast

Source: NBS, Authors Calculation

Though the NBS continues to run with the line that linking the old and new CPI series is incomparable, it curiously has a 12-month average CPI series which is doing exactly that.  This selective application and interpretation of data points across the old and new CPI series are troubling, particularly in light of the NBS’s earlier disavowal of its own historical inflation series—labelled “erroneous”—which has cast a shadow on the bureau’s credibility. Operationally, the agency also appears to be slipping: the main NBS website is increasingly outdated, and users are now forced to navigate a separate “micro-data” portal to access basic statistics. Data on food, transport, kerosene, and LPG prices are missing or delayed.

At a time when Nigeria’s policymakers are courting global investors with a reform agenda, the NBS should serve as a reliable and transparent source of macroeconomic evidence. Instead, its current disarray risks sending the wrong signal. For any serious investor attempting to conduct due diligence, the state of the NBS is more likely to land Nigeria in the “not worth the effort” folder. The bureau urgently needs to rebuild its credibility and functionality.

2024 Fiscal Accounts: CBN data release counters Finance Ministry: In my last note, I referenced the 2024 fiscal figures released by Nigerian policymakers during the IMF Spring Meetings. Those numbers painted a relatively contained picture: NGN20.8 trillion in revenues, NGN26.1 trillion in expenditures, and a fiscal deficit of NGN6.6 trillion—surprisingly behind target deficit numbers and certainly better than my own expectations.

However, the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) has now released its own version of events via its Q4 2024 statistical bulletin, and the picture could not be more different. According to the CBN, the actual federal fiscal deficit stood at a staggering NGN15.5 trillion, or 5.6% of GDP—more than double the earlier reported figure. The primary source of this divergence lies in revenues. The CBN puts federally retained revenue at NGN9.4 trillion—about 55% lower than what the Finance Ministry shared with international investors. In its presentation, the Finance Ministry included revenues that belong to the Federation Account and Government-Owned Enterprises (GOEs) as part of the FGN’s take, without making the corresponding adjustments on the expenditure side when calculating the deficit. In its data, the CBN data show that debt service costs (NGN11trillion) exceeded FGN revenues which is rather troubling. I suspect we will see some rejoinders, but this is the opposite of the fiscal consolidation that has been touted.

Figure 3: Nigeria’s Fiscal Accounts

Source: CBN, Finance Ministry

Back to the issue of data transparency, we’re nearly halfway through the year, and the Budget Office—the official source for fiscal data—has yet to publish anything beyond H1 2024. As I’ve noted before, for a government actively travelling the globe to court foreign capital, basic credibility starts with accurate and transparent reporting at home. These glaring inconsistencies across official fiscal data sources not only muddy the waters for analysts and investors but also make life unnecessarily difficult for ratings agencies. It’s hard to inspire confidence in Nigeria’s reform story when the numbers simply don’t add up.

Fixing this begins with halting the hollowing out of federal ministries—a trend that has continued unchecked through the proliferation of mushroom agencies carved out of core ministerial functions. Nowhere is this fragmentation more evident than in the finance ministry. Traditionally, the finance ministry—or treasury—is one of the great institutions of state and should be staffed with professionals, operating with the same institutional integrity and independence as its monetary policy counterpart, the Central Bank. In Nigeria, however, the finance ministry has been systematically weakened through the creation of parallel agencies: the Budget Office, the Debt Management Office, the Federal Inland Revenue Service, and even a separate Budget and Planning Ministry. This diffusion of responsibility undermines the central authority and effectiveness of the treasury function. The problem is further compounded by the overreliance on ministerial aides and special assistants who often operate outside the formal civil service structure, diluting institutional memory and professionalism. As a result, the finance ministry lacks the basic transparency expected of such a critical institution—unlike the CBN, its website carries no fiscal data, leaving Nigerian citizens to depend on investor roadshow decks to understand their own government’s fiscal performance.

The title of the finance minister is coordinating minister of the economy. Its time to create a framework for proper coordination.  I will propose a few ideas below

1. Legislative and Structural Reform: Consolidate Core Fiscal Functions

  • Merge budget, tax, and debt functions under a single, empowered Ministry of Finance. This should be done through legislation (e.g., a “Treasury Reform Act”) that repeals duplicative mandates. 
  • Eliminate overlapping mandates among the Budget Office, DMO, FIRS, and the Budget Ministry. These entities should become departments within the Ministry, not standalone silos.
  • Define and protect the Ministry’s core remit—fiscal policy, debt management, revenue strategy, and budget execution.

2. Build a Professional, Technocratic Civil Service Core

  • Recruit and retain a professional cadre of economists, accountants, statisticians, and policy experts under a competitive, merit-based structure (e.g., modelled after the UK HM Treasury or U.S. Treasury).
  • Create a Treasury Executive Service—a career path within the ministry for high-caliber civil servants with technical expertise.  
  • Limit reliance on personal aides or political appointees for technical work. Advisors should support, not substitute, the professional civil service.

3. Restore and Institutionalize Data Transparency

  • Establish a Fiscal Statistics & Research Department within the ministry, mandated to produce regular, comprehensive fiscal reports—revenues, expenditures, financing—on a monthly and quarterly basis.
  • Make the Finance Ministry’s website the primary portal for fiscal information, with historical datasets, charts, and metadata.
  • Require statutory deadlines for fiscal reporting and empower the Auditor-General to certify data integrity.

4. Create an Integrated Public Financial Management (PFM) Framework

  • Link the budget planning, execution, and reporting processes through a single treasury management system—similar to Ghana’s GIFMIS or Uganda’s IFMIS. 

5. Strengthen Legal Oversight and Parliamentary Scrutiny

  • Require the finance ministry to submit mid-year and year-end fiscal performance reviews to the National Assembly.
  • Codify penalties for inaccurate or misleading public finance data—this builds accountability and trust.

By reversing fragmentation, injecting professional capacity, and improving data transparency, Nigeria can rebuild a finance ministry that is fit for purpose and respected both domestically and internationally. The goal should be a strong, technocratic treasury function that plays a central role in macroeconomic management.


Discover more from Eco215

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Discover more from Eco215

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Scroll to Top