Headline inflation rose in September, but m/m trends in farm produce suggest an inflection point: The National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) put out September CPI inflation data which showed another leg-up in the annualized headline inflation to 26.72% (August: 25.8%) which appears driven by food inflation at 30.6% relative to core inflation at 21.85%. However, the monthly data provide a different nuance as the September print came at 2.1%, down 110bps from the prior month driven by a big moderation in monthly food inflation to 2.45% from 3.9% in the prior month. Most of this reflects a deceleration in monthly farm produce inflation to 2.12% (from the 4.2% splash in August) amid flat trends in petrol prices over the month. This would suggest the onset of the main harvest season in Nigeria is driving a slowdown in the food prices from recent highs. This effect is likely to continue over Q4 2023, absent any big supply shocks or energy price hikes leading to muted monthly readings. However the annualized print will remain on the high-side though on my numbers the subdued monthly prints means while we are likely to run close to 30% we are unlikely to get there in the remaining three months of 2023.
Figure: Nigeria 2023 Inflation: Actual and Forecast

Source: NBS, Authors calculation
Latest money supply data reveals big drop in net foreign assets: The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) updated data on monetary aggregates through September 2023 which showed that money supply growth remained in expansionary mode with M3 and M2 running at annualized run rates of 38%. From a structural perspective, the breakdowns put this growth down to rapid expansion in net domestic assets (+52% annualized) largely driven by credit growth of similar magnitude. Much of the growth in credit is driven by an expansion in credit to the private sector (+54% annualized to NGN58.6trillion or an increase of NGN16.9trillion in nominal terms) largely reflecting the translation impact of NGN depreciation on USD loans in the banking system. Credit to the public sector is also running at a brisk pace (+52% annualized to NGN34trillion) but the m/m trend was negative in September and the pace generally sluggish over the last three months which would suggest the brakes have been applied on the CBN lending to FGN. But the most concerning point from the September release was the drop in net foreign assets to NGN591billion (down 86% from the end of 2022) since surging to a 43-month peak in June 2023 of NGN11trillion following the FX adjustments. The pattern over the subsequent months has been of a steady decline which would suggest either a drop in foreign assets or the consolidation of foreign liabilities. My inclination is towards the latter and my sense is the CBN which tweaked accounting rules in 2017 to shift FX swaps as an off-balance sheet (vs prior norm of on-balance sheet) is now, under pressure from the Special Presidential Auditor, moving this item back to an on-balance sheet definition. This would rightly position the CBN as net short USD and would be consistent with the limited ability to intervene across FX markets.
Nigeria’s oil production climbed further in September, but when do the swaps end? : Nigeria’s crude oil production rose to a twenty-month high of 1.57mbpd in September driven by big increases at Forcados (+91% to 275kbpd), improvements at Erha (+27% to 81kbpd), Usan (+65% to 40kpbpd) and Bonny (+10% to 140kpbpd). Pressures along onshore terminals at Brass, where output logged at 21kbpd (potential of 90-100kbpd) and Qua Iboe (operating some 80-90kbpd below capacity) and offshore fields like Egina and Agbami which are both presently running at 93kbpd but some 70-100kbpd below peak levels in 2020) remains the key drag preventing a return to 2mbpd. The onshore fields require some work on security while the offshore will require inducing the IOCs to invest in field work to expand production. Nigeria needs to re-engage the IOCs constructively with a firm commitment on avoiding the brinkmanship and bad-actor ways of the last decade ahead of what is shaping up to be a supportive oil price environment in the medium term. In the near term, the September data suggests that Nigeria’s oil sector likely exited recession in Q3 2023 which could provide a spring in overall growth for the period. That said, the improvement in production amid higher oil prices is yet to filter through to external reserves as the NNPC likely continues to pay down obligations on the much maligned Direct-Sale-Direct-Swap (DSDP) program that it discontinued in Q2. My sense is these obligations likely term out over H1 2024 thereupon which we see a recovery in domestic dollar liquidity.
Figure: Nigeria Oil Production by Regime

Source: NUPRC
Revealed medium term spending framework points to expansionary unreasonable fiscal spending plan in 2024: During the week, the minister of budget and national planning revealed the Medium-Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF) which sets out the three-year (2024-2026) budget cycle from which annual budgets will take root. The MTEF assumes a fiscal spending outlay of NGN26trillion in 2024 (+15% from 2023) driven by higher debt service (30% to NGN8.3trillion) and recurrent expenditure (+23% to NGN10.8trillion) with reduced capital expenditure (down 7%). To fund the budget, the FGN is forecasting revenues of NGN17trillion (up from NGN11trillion in 2023) underpinned by 3.4x rise in projected oil receipts to NGN7trillion, non-oil tax collections of NGN3.5trillion (+46%) and other revenues at NGN6.4trillion. The oil revenue data appear strangely bullish my sense is for a number in the NGN4trillion region while the non-oil receipts likely move towards NGN5-6trillion bringing total revenues to the 2023 levels. From here one returns to the Nigerian budget game where projected capex numbers are non-credible and usually a plug-in to get a budget that is digestible. A look at the 7M 2023 actual data reveals the capex implementation running 66% behind budget. Although the read-through for debt markets suggests lower paper supply, down 23% to NGN6trillion, I would caution that this remains a heavy number and could be an increment in actual terms as 2023 gross domestic borrowing is unlikely to hit the NGN7trillion target anyway with the Jan-October number running at NGN5.5trillion with two auctions left in the year.
Naira weakens across board despite recent CBN announcements: The Naira came under fresh pressure as the exchange rate fell 5% w/w to close at NGN808.27/$ in trading which included intra-day highs of over NGN900/$. The weakness followed the move to end the much maligned 43-items ban as well as the renaming of the Investors & Exporters Window (IEW) to Nigerian Autonomous Foreign Exchange Market (NAFEM). To my mind the former reflects another shift towards orthodoxy by the new CBN governor, which in the face of still limited USD supply within the segment portends fresh downside. In any case, pressures continued within the parallel market where the currency moved past the NGN1000/$ resistance level to NGN1142/$. Nigeria is in the throes of a currency crisis reflecting large encumbrances on petrodollar inflows and USD reserves which require a large BoP facility to stem the gap till the encumbrances are either restructured or term out. To be credible to potential external liquidity providers, Nigeria’s economic managers must be prepared to tighten monetary policy and embark on fiscal consolidation. The die is cast Nigeria must engage with multilateral financial institutions for concessionary funding as USD funding markets are closed to SSA sovereigns.
Figure: CBN USD sales to BDC operators and the parallel market premium

Source: CBN
Yields surge at the October 2023 bond auction: At the October bond sale where the DMO had NGN360billion on offer, demand remained soft (bid-cover: 1.1x) which forced yields higher with the 30-year printing at 16.6%. Despite selling around NGN350billion in the prior week in 10-year sukuk debt at 15.75%, the DMO would end up taking up around NGN375billion including non-competitive bids of NGN40billion. At 78% thus far, the DMO is someway towards its 2023 borrowing target and even in the face of a lower than target fiscal expenditure, the revenue challenges and likely unwillingness to draw on CBN financing appears to be forcing DMO to pay the market bid. With two months to go, one can sense this posture is unlikely to change cue the bear sentiments in secondary market bonds.
The state of Nigerian macro is weak driven by vulnerabilities in the external account occasioned by large encumbrances on oil export flows and USD reserves due to policies aimed at pretending about fuel prices and the exchange rate. To come to grips with the crisis, the current government must convene an economic war council to serve as an instant clearing room for dealing with issues at the high level in a systematic approach. Finding USD liquidity to tide over the present shortfalls is a critical priority but policymakers should be prepared to reach out for multilateral assistance to calm the current storm.
If you would like to receive this every week as well as other posts or you know someone who will find the information on this site useful, you can add your email using the subscribe button below
Discover more from Eco215
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.